Paint Seeker

For Creative Lifestyle

Behr Chalk Paint Vs Rust-Oleum Chalk Paint – Choosing the Right Chalk Paint

Behr Chalk Paint Vs Rust-Oleum Chalk Paint

Is there a significant difference between Behr chalk paint and Rust-Oleum chalk paint?

Rust-Oleum’s chalked paint may not be an exact carbon copy of traditional chalk paint, yet it holds its own with a comparable matte finish and seamless application. 

Notably, its water-based formulation simplifies cleanup and minimizes the risk of yellowing over time, preserving the integrity of your creations.

Meanwhile, Behr chalk paint, though not inherently requiring a sealant, can benefit from an added topcoat to enhance its longevity. 

It’s vital to differentiate Behr chalk paint from chalkboard paint tailored for chalk inscriptions emphasizing that they cater to distinct purposes.

This article explores and compares the two popular chalk paint brands in terms of their formulation, functionality, and application.

By examining their similarities and differences, readers will understand these products comprehensively and make informed decisions when selecting the most suitable option for their painting projects.

Chalk Paint Face-Off: Behr vs. Rust-Oleum

In this discussion, we will comprehensively compare two prominent contenders in the chalk paint arena: Behr and Rust-Oleum. Beyond the world of conventional paints, these brands have gained recognition for their unique formulations that bring a touch of vintage charm to any project. 

We will meticulously assess various aspects of their performance, helping you make an informed choice for your next creative endeavor. 

From consistency and coverage to drying time and finished aesthetics, join us as we dissect the nuanced qualities of Behr and Rust-Oleum chalk paints.

Whether you’re an experienced DIY enthusiast, an artist seeking new dimensions, or simply someone with an eye for exquisite transformations, this discussion will provide you with insights that illuminate the path to your perfect paint selection.

Consistency and Application

Behr Chalk Paint’s consistency is thicker than Rust-Oleum Chalk Paint, resulting in a slightly streaky application during the first coat. 

This can be attributed to the thicker texture of Behr Chalk Paint, which makes it more difficult to achieve a smooth and even finish.

The streakiness in the first coat of Behr Chalk Paint often necessitates the application of a second coat to achieve the desired coverage and eliminate any streaks.

In contrast, Rust-Oleum Chalk Paint demonstrates superior coverage in a single coat, with its thinner consistency allowing for a smoother and less streaky application.

This difference in consistency and application is an important factor to consider when choosing between Behr and Rust-Oleum Chalk Paint.

Coverage and Streaks

Rust-Oleum chalk paint provides better coverage per coat compared to Behr chalk paint. You may need fewer coats with Rust-Oleum to achieve a uniform and opaque finish.

Alternatively, Behr chalk paint tends to show more prominent streaks even after applying the second coat. 

This can be a concern for those looking for a smooth and streak-free finish. The presence of streaks can affect the overall appearance of the painted surface and may require additional coats to achieve the desired result.

Therefore, if comprehensive coverage and minimal streaks are important to you, Rust-Oleum might be the better choice.

Drying Time

Comparing the drying times of Behr and Rust-Oleum chalk paints reveals a notable disparity. 

While both paints claim to dry within 15 minutes, there are several factors to consider that can affect the actual drying time.

  1. Paint thickness: Behr chalk paint tends to have a thicker consistency compared to rust-leum, which can result in a longer drying time. The thicker the paint, the longer it takes to dry completely.
  2. Humidity levels: High humidity can prolong the drying time of both paints. Moisture in the air slows down the evaporation process, causing the paint to take longer to dry.
  3. Application method: How the paint is applied can also influence drying time. Using thin, even coats and allowing each coat to dry fully before applying the next can help speed up the drying process.

Finished Look

Behr chalk paint tends to show more streaks and may require multiple coats to achieve a smooth and even finish. 

Conversely, Rust-Oleum chalk paint offers better coverage with fewer streaks, resulting in a more polished and professional look. 

This difference in the finished appearance can be attributed to the formulation and pigmentation of the two paints. 

Rust-Oleum chalk paint is known for its highly pigmented and matte finish, which helps to mask imperfections and create a smoother surface. 

To provide a clearer comparison, the table below presents a summary of the differences in the finished look of Behr and Rust-Oleum chalk paints.

AspectBehr Chalk PaintRust-Oleum Chalk Paint
StreaksMore noticeableFewer noticeable
CoverageLess coverageBetter coverage
FinishLess polishedMore polished

Thicker Texture and Blending Possibilities

The slightly thicker texture of Behr chalk paint can result in a coat that thickens after application, making it more difficult to achieve a smooth and even finish.

In comparison, the smoother and more even texture of Rust-Oleum chalk paint facilitates blending, allowing for seamless transitions between colors and the creation of various decorative effects.

This texture difference also influences the level of control an artist has over the paint, as a smoother texture allows for easier manipulation and blending.

Color Range

Behr chalk paint offers a total of 45 colors to choose from, allowing users to find the perfect shade for their project. 

The range includes various hues, such as neutrals, pastels, and bold colors, catering to different aesthetic preferences.

On the flip side, Rust-Oleum chalk paint offers a more focused selection with 25 color options. While the range is smaller compared to Behr, Rust-Oleum still provides a variety of shades to suit different project needs.

This narrower selection may appeal to individuals who prefer a more streamlined and curated color palette.

Ease of Application

Rust-Oleum’s chalk paint has been found to provide a smoother and more even application compared to its competitor, Behr chalk paint. 

This can be attributed to the formulation and composition of Rust-Oleum’s paint, which allows for better adhesion and coverage on various surfaces.

Additionally, the consistency of the paint plays a vital role in its ease of application. 

Rust-Oleum’s chalk paint has a slightly thicker consistency, making it easier to control and apply without leaving streaks or brush marks.

Is Rust-Oleum chalked the same as chalk paint?

Regarding the comparison between Rust-Oleum chalked and traditional chalk paint, it is important to note that Rust-Oleum chalked is not classified as a true chalk paint due to its composition as an ultra matte latex paint. 

Unlike traditional chalk paint, which contains calcium carbonate, Rust-Oleum chalked does not have the same chalky texture or finish.

This distinction is reflected in the labeling of Rust-Oleum chalked as a ‘Chalky Finish’ rather than a ‘chalk paint.’ 

While both products can be used for similar purposes, such as creating a vintage or distressed look on furniture or other surfaces, the difference in composition may result in variations in application and durability.

Is rustoleum chalk paint oil or water based?

Rust-Oleum chalked paint is water based, meaning that it is primarily composed of water as its solvent. This composition allows for easy clean-up with soap and water.

The water base also contributes to the low odor of the paint, making it safe to use in enclosed spaces.

It is important to note that the water base of Rust-Oleum chalked paint does not compromise its ability to create a chalky, ultra-matte finish.

The paint adheres well to various surfaces and provides excellent coverage.

Additionally, the water base of Rust-Oleum chalked paint allows for easy application and smooth brush strokes.

Does Behr chalk paint need to be sealed?

Chalk paint typically has a matte finish and requires a special wax or sealant to protect and enhance its appearance. 

In the case of Behr chalk paint, it is recommended to apply a topcoat or sealant to ensure durability and longevity. This step is crucial as the paint alone does not have any gloss or sheen. 

By sealing the Behr chalk paint, you can achieve a smoother and more finished look while also providing added protection to the painted surface. 

To illustrate the differences between Behr chalk paint and Rust-Oleum chalk paint, refer to the table below:

 Behr Chalk PaintRust-Oleum Chalk Paint
Sealing RequiredYesYes
Topcoat OptionsWax or SealantWax or Sealant
ApplicationBrush or RollerBrush or Roller

Is Behr chalk paint chalkboard paint?

While Behr chalk paint is designed for upcycling and giving furniture pieces a decorative finish, chalkboard paint is specifically formulated to create a surface that can be written on with chalk.

Here are three key differences between Behr chalk paint and chalkboard paint:

  1. Purpose: Behr chalk paint is intended for decorative purposes, allowing users to transform and revitalize furniture pieces and accessories. Chalkboard paint, on the other hand, is specifically formulated to create a writable surface, typically used on walls, furniture, or other surfaces where users want to write or draw with chalk.
  2. Finish: Behr chalk paint provides a matte finish, giving the furniture a vintage, distressed look. In contrast, chalkboard paint provides a smooth, slate-like finish, enabling users to repeatedly write and erase chalk markings.
  3. Sealing: Behr chalk paint typically requires sealing with a wax or topcoat to protect the finish and enhance durability. Chalkboard paint, on the other hand, does not typically require sealing, as it is designed to be written on and erased without damaging the surface.

Chalk Paint Face-Off: Rust-Oleum vs Behr

The comparison between Behr chalk paint and Rust-Oleum chalk paint underscores significant distinctions. 

Rust-Oleum’s chalk paint boasts a thinner consistency that translates to smoother, less streaky application and superior coverage per coat. 

Its water-based formula guarantees effortless cleanup and a reduced likelihood of yellowing over time. 

Conversely, although Behr chalk paint does not require sealing, can benefit from a topcoat to bolster its durability. 

It’s crucial to distinguish between Behr chalk paint and chalkboard paint, designed exclusively for writing with chalk. 

Both options offer unique merits, culminating in a charming vintage aesthetic for your projects. 

With these insights, you can confidently navigate the world of chalk paints, making an informed choice tailored to your creative pursuits.

Behr Chalk Paint Vs Rust-Oleum Chalk Paint – Choosing the Right Chalk Paint

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Scroll to top